top of page

How to Help Your Parents Spot and Avoid Medicare Scams

Nov 1
8 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

A phone call that sounds official can turn stressful fast. A friendly voice says there is a problem with a Medicare card, a new benefit is available, or a deadline is approaching. On television, an ad promises extra benefits and urges viewers to call now. For many older adults, the message feels urgent, confusing, and hard to verify.


The best help starts before there is a crisis. A simple family plan, a few clear rules, and regular check-ins can make it much easier for your Parents to pause, verify, and avoid giving sensitive information to the wrong person.


Medicare Scams often work because they sound familiar. Scammers use real Medicare terms, mention benefits people have heard about, and create pressure to act quickly. Education works best when it is practical, respectful, and repeated over time.


Eye-level view of an older adult holding a phone at a kitchen table with Medicare mail nearby
A calm setting makes it easier to talk through suspicious calls before they happen.

Start with a respectful conversation, not a warning lecture


Many people feel embarrassed after answering a suspicious call or clicking on a questionable ad. If the conversation starts with fear or blame, they may avoid bringing it up next time. The goal is to create a safe habit: pause, ask, and verify.


A helpful opening might sound like this:


“There are a lot of Medicare-related calls and TV ads right now. Some are legitimate, and some are not. Let’s make a simple plan so you do not have to decide on the spot.”

This keeps the focus on the tactic, not the person. Scammers are trained to sound convincing. Anyone can be targeted.


A good first conversation should cover three ideas:


  • Medicare information is sensitive

    A Medicare number should be treated like a credit card or Social Security number. It should not be shared with someone who calls unexpectedly.


  • Urgency is a warning sign

    Scammers often say benefits will be canceled, a new card is required, or an offer expires immediately. Real government programs do not usually require instant decisions over the phone.


  • Verification is normal

    Hanging up and calling a known official number is not rude. It is the safest next step.


Try to agree on one family rule that is easy to remember:


If someone calls about Medicare, do not give information during that call. Hang up and call Medicare, the plan, or a trusted family contact using a number you already know is real.


That one rule can prevent many problems.


Know the common Medicare scam tactics


Scams change over time, but the basic methods stay fairly consistent. Reviewing common examples helps older adults recognize patterns instead of trying to judge every call from scratch.


Fake Medicare representatives


A caller may claim to be from Medicare and say they need to “confirm” a Medicare number, Social Security number, birth date, or bank information. The reason may sound routine, such as updating records or sending a new card.


A safer response:


“I do not give personal information over incoming calls. I will call Medicare directly.”

Then hang up. Use 1-800-MEDICARE or the number printed on an official plan card.


Free medical equipment offers


Scammers may offer braces, pain creams, diabetic supplies, testing kits, or other products at “no cost.” They may say Medicare will pay for everything, but they still need the Medicare number to process the order.


The problem is that “free” equipment can lead to fraudulent billing. It may also result in products a doctor never ordered and the patient does not need.


A good rule:


Do not accept medical equipment, tests, or supplies from a caller unless a personal doctor has ordered them.


New card or replacement card scams


Some scams claim that Medicare is issuing new cards and that the current card will stop working unless the person verifies information. This can sound believable because Medicare cards and plan cards do change at times.


The safer path is to check directly with Medicare or the insurance plan. Do not rely on the phone number the caller provides.


Refund, rebate, or benefit scams


A caller or mailer may say the person qualifies for a refund, grocery benefit, dental benefit, or lower premium. Some benefits may exist through certain Medicare Advantage or other plans, but scammers use the same language to collect personal information.


A key question helps:


“Can I verify this through my plan using the number on my card?”


If the caller avoids that question or pressures for an immediate answer, stop the conversation.


TV ads that blur the line


Not every Medicare-related television ad is a scam. Some promote real insurance products. The concern is that ads can make broad promises, use fast disclaimers, or imply that everyone qualifies for extra benefits.


A TV ad should be treated as a starting point for research, not a reason to enroll immediately. Before calling a number from an ad, look up the company, compare the offer with the current plan, and contact a neutral source such as the local State Health Insurance Assistance Program, often called SHIP.


Teach a simple pause-and-check system


A system works better than a long list of warnings. The person receiving the call, letter, or ad needs something they can do in the moment.


Use a three-step process: pause, protect, verify.


Pause before responding


Scammers want a fast answer. They may keep talking so the person does not have time to think. Encourage a habit of slowing the interaction down.


Helpful phrases include:


  • “I do not make decisions on incoming calls.”

  • “Please send information by mail.”

  • “I need to speak with my family before I make any changes.”

  • “I will call the official number myself.”


If the caller becomes impatient or rude, that is another warning sign.


Protect personal information


Personal information should not be shared just because the caller already knows a name, address, or date of birth. Scammers often have some information already. They use it to sound legitimate.


Information to protect includes:


  • Medicare number

  • Social Security number

  • Bank account or credit card numbers

  • Date of birth

  • Full address

  • Online account passwords

  • One-time passcodes sent by text or email

  • Current health plan details


One-time passcodes matter. A scammer may say they “sent a code to verify identity.” That code may actually let them access an account. Do not read codes to unexpected callers.


Verify with a trusted source


Verification means using a number or website found independently. Do not use the contact information supplied by the suspicious caller, email, postcard, or TV ad until it has been checked.


Trusted sources may include:


  • The number on the back of a Medicare Advantage, Part D, or Medigap plan card

  • 1-800-MEDICARE

  • Medicare.gov

  • The local SHIP office

  • A known doctor’s office or pharmacy

  • A trusted licensed insurance agent already used by the family


For claims or suspicious billing, review the Medicare Summary Notice or Explanation of Benefits. Look for services, equipment, tests, or providers that are unfamiliar.


Close-up of a hand writing a short call safety checklist beside a household phone
A written checklist can turn a stressful call into a routine decision.

Make television ads easier to evaluate


Television ads can be especially confusing because they often mix real terms with broad promises. The ad may mention dental, vision, hearing, transportation, grocery cards, or money back. Some benefits are real for certain plans in certain counties, but eligibility varies.


A good approach is to separate the ad into questions.


Ask:


  1. Is this Medicare itself or a private insurance company?


    Medicare is a federal program. Many TV ads are from private companies, agencies, or lead generators. That does not automatically make them bad, but it changes how the offer should be reviewed.


  2. Does this apply in the person’s ZIP code?


    Medicare Advantage and Part D plan options vary by location. A benefit shown in an ad may not be available everywhere.


  3. Does the benefit require changing plans?


    Extra benefits may come with network rules, drug formulary changes, prior authorization, or different out-of-pocket costs.


  4. Will current doctors and medications still be covered?


    A plan may sound attractive but create problems if a doctor is out of network or a medication costs more.


  5. Is the caller collecting information before explaining the plan?


    Be cautious if the conversation quickly turns to Medicare numbers, birth dates, or bank details.


If an ad catches their attention, suggest a safer process:


  • Write down the company name and offer.

  • Do not call immediately during the ad.

  • Compare plans through Medicare.gov or with SHIP.

  • Review doctors, hospitals, prescriptions, premiums, deductibles, copays, and maximum out-of-pocket costs.

  • Avoid changing coverage during a rushed phone call.


This approach respects their interest in saving money or improving benefits while adding a verification step.


Set up practical safeguards at home


Education is strongest when the home environment supports it. A few simple safeguards can reduce exposure and make suspicious contacts easier to handle.


Create a Medicare contact sheet


Place a one-page contact sheet near the phone or on the refrigerator. Keep it simple.


Include:


  • Medicare, 1-800-MEDICARE

  • Current health plan customer service number

  • Prescription drug plan number, if separate

  • Primary doctor’s office

  • Pharmacy

  • SHIP contact information

  • A trusted family contact


Add one sentence at the top:


Do not give Medicare, Social Security, bank, or credit card information to anyone who calls unexpectedly.


Use call blocking tools


Many phones and carriers offer call blocking or spam labeling. These tools do not stop every unwanted call, but they can reduce volume.


Options may include:


  • Built-in smartphone spam filters

  • Carrier call protection apps

  • Landline call blocking devices

  • Contacts-only settings for certain phones

  • Voicemail screening


If your family member uses a smartphone, help label trusted contacts clearly. Unknown callers can go to voicemail. A legitimate caller can leave a message.


Review Medicare paperwork together


Set a routine to review Medicare Summary Notices, Explanation of Benefits statements, and plan mail. This can be monthly or quarterly.


Look for:


  • Services not received

  • Equipment not ordered

  • Providers not recognized

  • Duplicate charges

  • Tests that were not discussed with a doctor


If something looks wrong, call the provider or plan using a known number. If it still seems suspicious, report it.


Keep documents secure


Medicare cards, plan cards, and medical bills should not be left out when visitors, contractors, or caregivers are in the home unless there is a reason. Shred old documents that include personal information.


Do not carry every insurance card every day unless needed. Many people only need the cards required for that day’s appointment or pharmacy visit.


Know what to do if information was shared


If a Medicare number, Social Security number, or financial information was shared with a suspicious caller, respond quickly but calmly. Shame and panic make it harder to fix the problem.


Start with these steps:


  1. Write down what happened


    Include the date, time, phone number if available, what was requested, and what information was shared.


  2. Call Medicare or the plan


    Use the official number on the card or 1-800-MEDICARE. Ask how to flag potential fraud and watch for suspicious claims.


  3. Review recent medical claims


    Check for unfamiliar services, tests, or equipment.


  4. Contact the bank or credit card company if financial details were shared


    Ask about freezing or replacing cards, changing account access, and monitoring transactions.


  5. Report the incident


    Reports can be made to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. Medicare-related fraud can also be reported to Medicare. The Senior Medicare Patrol program can help people recognize and report suspected Medicare fraud.


If a Social Security number was shared, consider placing a fraud alert or credit freeze with the major credit bureaus. This can help reduce the risk of new accounts being opened fraudulently.


Build confidence through repetition


One conversation is helpful, but repeated reminders work better. Scammers call at inconvenient times, use new scripts, and create emotional pressure. A short review every few months can keep the safety plan fresh.


Try this simple routine:


  • Ask if any Medicare calls, mail, or TV offers seemed confusing.

  • Review one recent example together.

  • Update the trusted contact sheet.

  • Check whether call blocking is still working.

  • Review any Medicare notices for unfamiliar claims.


The goal is not to make someone afraid of every call or ad. The goal is to make verification feel normal. When older adults know they have a clear process, they can respond with confidence instead of pressure.


A good rule to leave them with is simple:


No urgent caller gets personal information. No TV ad gets an immediate enrollment decision. Every Medicare offer can wait long enough to be checked.



This article is for general educational purposes only. It is not medical, legal, tax, or financial advice. Medicare rules, plan availability, premiums, provider networks, drug formularies, and benefits can change. Always review official Medicare materials and plan documents before enrolling or changing coverage.


We are hear to help at anytime. Contact us.

David L. Goubeaux, Life, Health, AHIP



 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page